A year ago, I was slogging through the literature review for my D.Min. dissertation. (As an aside, can we all agree “D.Min.” is the absolute worst abbreviation for a ministry degree…?) I’d agonized over my topic for months and finally settled on what was, at the time, a source of profound stress for me: how Christian writers are required to promote their work in digital spaces, while somehow also maintaining their spiritual well-being.
Some (Seemingly) Sorrowful Findings
My literature review examined the reasons that writers—and specifically Christian nonfiction authors—are frequently expected to boast large online platforms even (and especially) before securing publishing contracts. It also considered how even writers who choose to publish apart from traditional institutions must be digitally savvy if they have any hope of reaching readers or earning an income. The literature review was by far the most tedious part of the dissertation, but it was also the most revelatory. Many of my more pessimistic suspicions about publishing in the digital age were confirmed, including the following:
Digital platforms enable easy and instant self-publishing (both of books and blogs), which has contributed to a lot of slop—and not just AI slop. 100% organic, human-produced garbage. There are more published words than ever before, but a great deal of them are not worth reading. However, a great deal of them might have become worth reading if they had been subjected to the rigors of traditional editing.
Social media has homogenized and further commercialized publishing. Books have always been commercial products, and thus subject to the tides of supply and demand. But publishing in the digital age has become more similar to the fast-fashion industry. If a certain genre, style, or aesthetic trends on Bookstagram or BookTok, publishers rush to pump out thousands of similar books—hence the avalanche of romantasy books with titles like A Jumble of Jots and Tittles or A Court of Quantity over Quality, as well as highly formulaic, cartoon-covered “clean” romances.
The most successful writers are, often, the most strategic marketers. I find Rupi Kaur to be an abysmal poet. I remember skimming her debut book in the Cambridge Waterstones. I had to purchase a Tennyson collection to recover. But it is hard to dispute the fact that she is a brilliant businesswoman. She promoted her verses with remarkable digital acumen, playing to Instagram’s aesthetics and algorithmic preference for the concise and generic. She may as well take credit for the flourishing contemporary genre known as “Instapoetry.”
Publishers give contracts to authors with large followings because, while millions of online followers do not necessarily translate to millions of books sold, these writers certainly sell more books than purists who refuse to work on their digital presence. Singer-songwriter Billie Eilish’s book is a notorious failure. Her publisher assumed her followers would order copies and they would easily rake in profits. And yet, Eilish’s book is considered a flop because it only sold a few tens of thousands of copies. This does not, as some posit, prove that digital fame does not matter. Instead, it shows that fame is not a guaranteed indicator of publishing success. But let’s be brutally honest: Eilish’s book sales still surpass those of most vocational authors, especially Christian authors, by thousands. Why? Because she is famous.
My Change of Heart
I acknowledge that the above findings sound rather pessimistic. Indeed, digital pessimism seems to be the default disposition of writers online. Substack and Threads are populated with writers who are eager to gripe about using digital platforms to build their author platforms, and who proceed to gain traction with other writers who are eager to commiserate. Griping about platforms is an effective—if painfully ironic—way to build one’s platform. I admit that I began my dissertation research because I, too, was annoyed with having to invest in digital promotion. Before signing my first book contract, I was rejected several times because, although publishers generally liked my writing and topic, my digital presence was not large enough. In other words, my work was not yet a predictably profitable investment.
I remember, too, attending my first writers conference. There, the recurring emphasis was platform, platform, platform. There was one workshop on deep point of view. Every other breakout session focused on building and maintaining an online presence. I was disenchanted, but not discouraged, and set about refining my blog and social media. I am far from an influencer, but I have found a few ways to connect with my ideal readers without feeling icky, stooping to trendy silliness, or pumping out content just for content’s sake.
But back to my dissertation. I expected to be vindicated by the literature review. I set about my research with fervor, eager to unmask the evils of publishing in the digital era and to stand tall as “a lone reed…waving boldly in the corrupt sands of commerce.” (If you know, you know.)1
This is not what happened.
I did not emerge from my literature review renewed in my righteous wrath, eager to cut the cords of my devices and return to the spiritually superior scribal materials of papyrus or, even better, clay tablets. No, I turned in my literature review with resignation and, to my surprise, gratitude.
Digital platforms are here to stay. Which ones? That may vary. Substack is on the ascent, but I suspect it will rise and fall like many other sites before it. Digital writing, however, is not going anywhere. Likewise, author platforms will continue to be a factor in publishers’ decision-making. Some publishers will care more, some will care less, but it is almost always a net win for authors to have a significant or, at least, consistent online presence in some form or fashion.
And I am fine with that.
I’m not mad.
I’m not bitter.
Sure, I struggle with envy when I see a writer have more online success than me—especially when I suspect their profile and person are not totally in sync. However, I repent of my tendency toward comparison and refuse to rage against the machine when, really, my sin is the problem. Instead of solidifying me in my digital bitterness, my dissertation awoke within me a latent digital gratitude.
A More Optimistic Take
Let’s revisit those findings I shared earlier.
Digital platforms enable easy and instant self-publishing, which has contributed to an abundance of resources by gifted writers who might otherwise never have been read. I can benefit from the wisdom of stay-at-home moms, scribbling away in another state. I can feast upon biblical exposition from pastors in other countries. I can continue to savor the poetry of friends who have since moved far away. A few thousand followers seems rather piddly in our era of digital superabundance, but in any previous age, for a no-name pastor’s wife in eastern Iowa (hi, it’s me!) to be able to reach this many readers would be nothing short of astonishing. Yes, there’s a great deal of garbage online, but there is also so much beauty, truth, and goodness as well.
Social media has helped preserve publishing. Think this sounds hyperbolic? Think again. In college, I drove by a boarded-up Barnes & Nobles and nearly wept. I remember when many of us thought brick-and-mortar bookstores were going extinct. BookTok and Bookstagram promote a lot of shallow, trashy books. But let’s give credit where credit is due: they also helped save publishing, as indicated by the resurrection of real-life bookstores. Barnes & Noble acknowledges this and is flourishing once more. As much as I cringe when I pass the “As Seen on BookTok” table, I have to be grateful. I can go in-person to purchase a copy of Sigrid Undset’s Nobel Prize-winning Kristin Lavransdatter because thousands of social media girlies convinced each other to go buy Fourth Wing. Yes, publishing has become more commercialized, but at least it’s still alive, and for that we should be thankful.
The most successful writers are, often, also strategic marketers. Today, authors who find the most commercial success combine artistry and entrepreneurship. I still grow frustrated when I see celebrities and influencers who are not, primarily, writers scooping up book deals. But I am also reminded of meeting with a professor before I graduated college. I told her I wanted to write and teach, focusing on theology and the arts. She sagely pointed out that, although I was academically gifted, I did not have the temperament of an academic. I was more pragmatic—”entrepreneurial” was the word she employed—and she did not think I’d enjoy being cooped up in the realm of theory when I could be working as a practitioner. I have become grateful for the way digital platforms enable me to write and research, as well as to put my findings to more immediate, practical work—hence this post! I am thankful to live in the age of the author-preneur. I love the practical opportunities and creative possibilities that digital platforms afford, and am thankful that they allow me to write consistently without sacrificing my more tangible work.
It’s true: publishers tend to give contracts to authors with large digital followings. But this is not purely selfish. It is not simply about sales and earnings. Rather, looking at authors’ platforms can (ideally) benefit readers. What I did not realize before diving into my research is that publishers often seek authors with large platforms because this helps them identify new and eager readerships, enabling them to produce materials for groups they may otherwise have overlooked. For example, an editor in New York might look at the growing platform of a midwestern writer and discover that rural Iowans want a very different type of book than urban executives. In this, then, authors’ online platforms (in theory) serve readers who want books more suited to their tastes, as well as publishers who need to make a good return on investment. An author’s platform is not just about self-promotion; it’s about bridging the gap between publishers and readers.
I Might as Well Say It
Considering that my printed dissertation is quite bulky, I know I have missed many other key takeaways. Frankly, I just don’t feel like rereading it right now to figure out which ones. (Remember how I said that I am academic but not an academic?) However, I hope that the tidbits I shared here help you see how some of the most common complaints cited by Christian writers in the digital age are also potential reasons for gratitude.
Not all platforms are created equal. Some are more useful (not to mention healthier) than others. I do not dispute the dangers of unmitigated and unmonitored digital use. But I also want to be fair: I doubt that I would be a published author were it not for digital platforms. I don’t live in a publishing hub, but am able to reach editors with the click of a few buttons. I have forged essential publishing connections through digital platforms. I completed my doctorate partly in-person and partly online. My book launched online, has been promoted online, and is primarily purchased online.
You are reading these words online.
I might as well admit it: I am a Christian writer with a middling online presence, but I am nonetheless thankful for digital platforms!
Thank you for reading. If you enjoyed this post, consider subscribing for free using the box below. I plan to share more significant findings regarding digital strategies and principles for protecting spiritual well-being in future posts—but only if this one goes viral, of course.
Thanks again! If you would like to help me translate the unseen firing of my brain’s neurons into printed, published words, you can buy me a coffee below:
- This is a quote from You’ve Got Mail, which I have not watched in six years. I think it’s time for a movie night… ↩︎
